Deliberation of utilization of Post Occupancy Evaluation Methods assessment of Health Care Facilities in Iran’s Society for

Author
sajjad Akbari Balderlou
head of design deputy-Abad consulting engineers
Abstract
Test of a sample approach of post occupancy evaluation (POE) methods for assessing health care spaces in Rasht (the capital of Guilan province, Iran) carried out through this study. The primary results of questionnaires compared to outcomes of controlling tools of the very same POE protocol, results of the following conducted interviews and qualitative analysis of variances in gathered data emerged Some social concept and factors assumed to be reasons of difference between findings of parallel ways; apparently influencing the assessment of built environment. On a macro scale of sociology these concepts were Apathy, Ignorance, Normlessness and Fear where on an operational scale the study addresses social concepts like Social situation, Active participation, Illiteracy , Lying, Reluctance to written participation, Lack of Inter-subjectivity , Peer pressure as well as more specific details like Time spent in space , Zoning and Who knows what. The applied POE (referring its validity to data gathering from real users of space) was an approach claiming to be an international tool for architecture evaluation free of cultural context might be used at. The test result indicates that previously mentioned social factors in Iran highly influence the findings and provide uncertain and invalid data if not considered in POE studies. The applied POE (referring its validity to data gathering from real users of space) was an approach claiming to be an international tool for architecture evaluation free of cultural context might be used at. The test result indicates that previously mentioned social factors in Iran highly influence the findings and provide uncertain and invalid data if not considered in POE studies. The applied POE (referring its validity to data gathering from real users of space) was an approach claiming to be an international tool for architecture evaluation free of cultural context might be used at. The test result indicates that previously mentioned social factors in Iran highly influence the findings and provide uncertain and invalid data if not considered in POE studies. The applied POE (referring its validity to data gathering from real users of space) was an approach claiming to be an international tool for architecture evaluation free of cultural context might be used at. The test result indicates that previously mentioned social factors in Iran highly influence the findings and provide uncertain and invalid data if not considered in POE studies. The applied POE (referring its validity to data gathering from real users of space) was an approach claiming to be an international tool for architecture evaluation free of cultural context might be used at. The test result indicates that previously mentioned social factors in Iran highly influence the findings and provide uncertain and invalid data if not considered in POE studies.

Keywords

● داور پناه, محمد رضا) 1386 (. ارتباط علمی: نیاز اطلاعاتی و رفتار اطلا عیابی. تهران : دبیزش؛ چاپار.
● راپاپورت, اموس) 1384 (. معنی محیط ساخته شده. تهران : انتشارات پردازش و برنامه ریزی شهری)وابسته به شهرداری تهران(.
● رفیع پور, فرامرز) 1387 (. تکنی کهای خاص تحقیق در علوم اجتماعی. تهران : شرکت سهامی انتشار.
● عضدانلو, حمید) 1384 (. آشنایی با مفاهیم اساسی جامعه شناسی. تهران : نشر نی.
● گیدنز, آنتونی) 1386 . جامعه شناسی، تهران : نشر نی.
● لوبون, گوستاو) 1371 (. روانشناسی تود هها. تهران : انتشارات روشنگران.
● A primer on post-occupancy evaluation. Architecture (AIA Journal) 70(13):5259-. Zimring, C. M. ,. 1981, Architecture (AIA
Journal), p. 5259-.
Argyris, C. , and Schon, D. (1978). Organizational Learning. Reading, Mass. : Addison-Wesley.
● Baird, G. , Gray, J. , Isaacs, N. , Kernohan, D. , and McIndoe, G.(1996). Building Evaluation Techniques. Wellington, New
Zealand : McGraw-Hill.
● Brand, S. (1994). How Buildings Learn, What Happens After They’re Built. New York : Penguin Books.
● Cooper, C. (1973). Comparison Between Architects’ Intentions and Residents’ Reactions, Saint Francis Place San Francisco.
Berkeley, Calif : Center for Environmental Structure.
● Councils, National Research. (1987). Post-Occupancy Evaluation Practices in the Building Process: Opportunities for
Improvement. Washington, D. C : National Academy Press.
● Dillon, R. , and Vischer, J. (1988). The Building-in-Use Assessment Methodology. Ottawa : Public Works Canada.
● Evaluation, reprogramming and re-design of redundant space for Children’s Hospital in Cincinnati. Stroppel, Preiser. 1996.
Barcelona : s. n. , (1996). Euro FM/IFMA Conference.
● Farbstein, J. , and Kantrowitz, M. (1989). Post-occupancy evaluation and organizational development: The experience of the
United States Postal Service. In Preiser, W. (Ed. ) Building Evaluation. New York : Plenum Press.
● Friedmann, A. , Zimring, C. , and Zube, E. (1978). Environmental Design Evaluation. New York : Plenum Press.
● Gibson, E. J. (1982). Working with the Performance Approach in Building. Rotterdam, Holland. : CIB Report, Publication 64. ,
1982. CIB Report.
● International Standards for Quality Management, 4th Edition. Geneva, Switzerland. International Standards for Quality
Management, 4th Edition. Geneva, Switzerland. : s. n. l Standards for Quality Management.
● Kaplan, R. S. , and Norton, D. P. (1996). The Balanced Scorecard. Boston : Harvard Business School Press.
● Knocke, J. (1996). Knocke, J. (1996). A Model Post-Construction Liability and Insurance System. Rotterdam : prepared under
the supervision of CIB.
● Lynn, M. (1998). The Need to Adopt an Auditable Commercial Real Estate Building Measurement Standard for Purposes of
Securities Disclosure (A Ticking Time Bomb). s. l. : International Center for Facilities.
● Mill, P. , and Kaplan, A. (1982). A Generic Methodology for Thermographic Diagnosis of Building Enclosures. Ottawa : Public
Works and Government Services Canada.
● Nasar, J. L. (Ed. ). (1988). Environmental Aesthetics: Theory, Methods and Applications. Cambridge, Mass. : MIT Press.
● Post-occupancy evaluations: "They show us what works and what doesn’t. ”. McLaughlin, H. 1997. 1997, Architectural Record
14.
● Preiser, W. F. E. (1999). Post-occupancy evaluation: Conceptual basis, benefits and uses. In: Stein, J. M. , and Spreckelmeyer,
K. F. New York : McGraw-Hill.
● Preiser, W. F. E. (1983). The habitability framework: A conceptual approach toward linking human behavior and physical
environment. s. l. : Design Studies.
● Preiser, W. F. E. , and Schramm, U. (1997). Building performance evaluation. In: Watson, D. , et al. New York : McGrow Hill.
● Raw, G. (1995). A Questionnaire for Studies of Sick Building Syndrome. London : BRE Report. , 1995. pp. 113. Raw, G.
(1995). A Questionnaire for Studies of Sick Building Syndrome. London. : BRE Report. Construction Research Communications.
, Construction Research Communications.
● Sannof, Henry. (1980). Methods of Architectural Programming. s. l. : Van Nostrand Reinhold.
● Sanoff, Henry. (2010). Democratic Design: Participation Case Studies in Urban and Small Town Environments. s. l. : VDM
Verlag Dr. Müller.
● Sanoff, Henry. (1980). Designing With Community Participation. New York : McGraw Hill Text.
● Sanoff, Henry. (1992). Integrating Programming, Evaluation and Participation in Design. s. l. : Avebury.
● Sanoff, Henry. (1990). Participatory Design: Theory and Techniques. s. l. : Henry Sanoff.
● Sanoff, Henry. (1968). Techniques of evaluation for designers (A Research Laboratory monograph). s. l. : Design Research
Laboratory, School of Design, North Carolina State University; 1st edition .
● Sanoff, Henry. (1991). Visual Research Methods in Design. s. l. : John Wiley & Sons Inc.
● Standardization, International Organization for. 1994. International Organization for Standardization. s. l. : ISO 9000
Compendium.
● Vischer, J. (1996). Workspace Strategies: Environment as a Tool for Work. New York : Chapman and Hall.