From Criteria to Construction: An Integrated Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Model for Optimal Wall and Façade System Selection

Document Type : Original Article

Author
Structural Retrofitting and Reconstruction Research Group, Natural Disaster Research Institute (NDRI), Tehran, Iran.
10.48311/bsnt.2025.117463.82891
Abstract
Aims: The selection of building envelope systems in Iranian construction is often subjective, lacking a systematic, evidence-based framework. This absence negatively impacts long-term building performance, cost efficiency, and overall sustainability. This research aims to develop a comprehensive Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) model for the systematic assessment and optimal selection of non-load-bearing wall and façade systems, specifically targeting mass housing projects.
 
Methods: This descriptive-analytical study identified 22 common systems and a comprehensive set of key evaluation criteria through extensive literature review and structured expert interviews. The relative importance (weights) of these criteria were quantified by professionals using a reliable Likert-scale questionnaire (Cronbach’s alpha: 0.885 for walls, 0.884 for façades). A second detailed questionnaire evaluated the performance of each system against these weighted criteria, with the analysis also considering Iran’s three major climatic zones.
 
Findings: For wall systems, "Nailability," "Weight," and "Enhancement of Space Efficiency" were identified as the most critical criteria, with AAC wall panels and AAC blocks ranking as the top-performing options. For façade systems, "Labor Cost," "Physical Durability," and "Material Cost" were the highest-priority factors, favoring Precast Concrete Façades and Dry Stone Façades. Region-specific rankings and detailed insights for climate-responsive design were also generated.
 
Conclusion: The primary outcomes are an adaptable analytical tool to help designers and managers select optimal system combinations based on project specifics, and a set of detailed executive drawings for the nine top-performing combinations. This research provides a structured, multi-criteria framework that enhances decision-making transparency, reduces subjectivity, and supports sustainable and cost-effective construction practices in Iran.

Highlights

Afghani Khoraskani R, et al. Guideline and booklet for designing details of peripheral walls and external facades of common buildings in Sarpol-e Zahab county with a climatic and environmental approach. Tehran: Housing Foundation of Islamic Revolution, Deputy of Reconstruction and Rural Housing; 2022. [In Persian].

Azizi MM. A study on housing indicators in different countries of the world. Tehran: National Land and Housing Organization, Office of Housing Planning and Economics; 1994. [In Persian].

Bahmani A, Ghaed Rahmati S. Evaluation of Mehr housing in terms of qualitative indicators of suitable housing (case study: 22 Bahman Mehr housing in Zanjan city). J Geogr Reg Dev. 2016;14(1):47–65. [In Persian].

Bolattürk A. Optimum insulation thicknesses for building walls with respect to cooling and heating degree-hours in the warmest zone of Turkey. Build Environ. 2008;43(6):1055–1064. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2007.02.014

Bolouhari S, Barbera L, Etessam I. Learning Traditional Architecture for Future Energy-Efficient Architecture in the Country; Case Study: Yazd City. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning, 2020 Sep 10;10(2):85-93. [Persian] https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1399.10.2.3.1. Available: https://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-39832-en.html

Cronbach LJ. Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Psychometrika. 1951;16(3):297–334. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02310555

Dombaycı ÖA, Gölcü M, Yürümez Y. The environmental impact of optimum insulation thickness for external walls of buildings. Build Environ. 2007;42(11):3855–3859. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2006.10.054

Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Earthquake-Resistant Design Concepts: An Introduction to the NEHRP Recommended Seismic Provisions for New Buildings and Other Structures (FEMA P-749). Washington (DC): FEMA; 2010.

Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Reducing the Risks of Nonstructural Earthquake Damage—A Practical Guide (FEMA E-74). Washington (DC): FEMA; 2012.

Gregory K, Moghtaderi B, Sugo H, Page A. Effect of thermal mass on the thermal performance of various Australian residential construction systems. Energy Build. 2008;40(4):459–465. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2007.04.001

Hassanisaleh S, Etessam I, Zabihi H. Media Beauty of Architectural Technology in Selected Monuments in Contemporary Architecture of Iran. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2021 Apr 10;11(1):37-52. [Persian] https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1400.11.1.5.8. Available at:

Keikha H, Ghodrati Amiri G. Developing a simplified method for analysis and design of isolated structures with the novel quintuple friction pendulum system under bidirectional near-field excitations. J Vib Control. 2023;29(1–2):453–465. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1177/10775463211048261

Keikha H, Ghodrati Amiri G. Numerical development and assessment of 3D quintuple friction pendulum isolator element based on its analytical and mathematical models. J Earthq Eng. 2021;25(13):2718–2757. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1080/13632469.2019.1643808

Keikha H, Ghodrati Amiri G. Seismic performance assessment of quintuple friction pendulum isolator with a focus on frictional behavior impressionability from velocity and temperature. J Earthq Eng. 2021;25(7):1256–1286. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1080/13632469.2019.1568929

Khasreen MM, Banfill PF, Menzies GF. Life-cycle assessment and the environmental impact of buildings: a review. Sustainability. 2009;1(3):674–701. Available from: https://doi.org/10.3390/su1030674

Maarefi A, TaghiZadeh K, Bayzidi Q, Hossainpour S. Improving Performance and Creativity of Students Focusing on BIM; Case Study Building Technical Design Course. Naqshejahan - Basic studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2021 Nov 10;11(3):93-108. [Persian] https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1400.11.3.3.0

Maghsoud M, Nasr T. ITC-based Technologies and Green Strategy for Contemporization of Tehran Silo. Naqshejahan-Basic studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2022 Mar 10;12(1):1-9. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1401.12.1.2.2

Mahdavinejad M, Doroodgar A, Mashayekhi M. Utilization of Wind Power as a Renewable Energy in Asbads, Case of Iran, Sistan. InAdvanced Materials Research 2012 (Vol. 433, pp. 1141-1145). Trans Tech Publications Ltd. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.433-440.1141

Mahdavinejad M, Matoor S, Fayaz R, Bemanian M. Estimation of daylight availability and illuminance on vertical south facing surfaces in Tehran. InAdvanced Materials Research 2012 (Vol. 518, pp. 1525-1529). Trans Tech Publications Ltd. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.518-523.1525

Al-Kazee MF, Negin Taji S, Nasr T, Mansoori R, Mahdavinejad M. Reframing the early-stage design process of residential buildings based on an energy-efficient, designerly decision support system (DDSS). FUTECH [Internet]. 2025 Apr. 14 [cited 2025 Apr. 15];4(2):30-4. Available from: https://fupubco.com/futech/article/view/285

Mahmoudi M, Nivi S. Improving of Climatic Technology According to Sustainable Development. Naqshejahan - Basic studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2011 Oct 10;1(1):35-52. [Persian] https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1390.1.1.7.0

Martabid JE, Mourgues C. Criteria used for selecting envelope wall systems in Chilean residential projects. J Constr Eng Manag. 2015;141(12):05015011. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001025

Medi H, Imani M. Biomimetic Technology and Learning from Nature. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2018; 8(1):47-55. Available at: https://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-26887-en.html

Mikaeili R, Karami E, Yousefi M. Investigation and analysis of quality assessment indicators of contemporary Iranian-Islamic housing based on the analytical hierarchy process method (case study: housing built in the last forty years). Islam Archit Urban Cult. 2021;6(1):18–38. [In Persian]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.52547/ciauj.6.1.19

Mokhtari L, Kariminia S, Kianersi M. Typology of general form and relative compactness of residential buildings in Tehran from the perspective of climatic performance and energy consumption optimization. Naqshejahan: Basic Stud New Technol Archit Plan. 2022;11(4):60–78.

Nahri Z, Motamedmanesh M. A New Perspective on Enhancing National Iranian Projects through Adoption of New Technologies. Naqshejahan-Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning, 2024;14(2):41-56. Available at: https://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-74129-en.html

Nahri Z, Motamedmanesh M. A new perspective on enhancing national Iranian projects through adoption of new technologies. Naqshejahan: Basic Stud New Technol Archit Plan. 2024;14(2):41–56.

Noorifard A, Mahdizadeh Saradj F, Vafamehr M. Conceptual assessment of seismic performance of nonstructural walls in conventional medium-rise buildings according to experiences of past earthquakes. Naqshejahan: Basic Stud New Technol Archit Plan. 2016;6(3):38–50.

Ortiz O, Castells F, Sonnemann G. Sustainability in the construction industry: a review of recent developments based on life cycle assessment. Constr Build Mater. 2009;23(1):28–39. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2007.11.012

Pahlavan A, Habib F, Zare L. Discussion New Technologies of Tehran’ High-Rise Residential Buildings’ Facade from the Perspective of Aesthetic Patterns. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2019 Sep 10;9(2):91-103. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1398.9.2.2.3

Plan and Budget Organization of Iran. Publication No. 326: Guideline for the design and execution of walls made of autoclaved aerated concrete (AAC) blocks. Tehran: Plan and Budget Organization; 2020. [In Persian].

Ranjazmay Azari M, Bemanian M, Mahdavinejad M, Körner A, Knippers J. Application-based principles of islamic geometric patterns; state-of-the-art, and future trends in computer science/technologies: a review. Heritage Science. 2023 Feb 1;11(1):22. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40494-022-00852-w

Rasoolzadeh M, Moshari M. Designerly approach to occupant health with the interaction of building material selection and healthy environment. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning, 2023;13(3):129-148. Available: http://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-73856-en.html

Rasoolzadeh M, Moshari M. Prioritizing for Healthy Urban Planning: Interaction of Modern Chemistry and Green Material-based Computation. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2021 May 10;11(1):94-105. [Persian] https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1400.11.1.7.0. Available: https://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-49429-en.html

Taghvaea A, Zabetian Toroghi E, Asgarizadeh Z. The use of new technologies in redevelopment brownfield. Naqshejahan - Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning. 2016 Nov 10;6(3):15-25. [Persian] https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1395.6.3.1.3

Talaei M, Mahdavinejad M, Zarkesh A, Haghighi HM. A review on interaction of innovative building envelope technologies and solar energy gain. Energy Procedia, 2017 Dec 1;141:24-8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2017.11.006

Zavadskas EK, Vilutienė T. A multiple criteria evaluation of multi-family apartment block maintenance contractors: I—Model for maintenance contractor evaluation and determination of selection criteria. Build Environ. 2006;41(5):621–632. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2005.02.019

 

 

Keywords

Subjects


  • بلوهری س، باربرا ل، اعتصام ا. یادگیری از معماری سنتی برای معماری آینده با بهره‌وری انرژی؛ مطالعه موردی: شهر یزد. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1399;10(2):85–93. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1399.10.2.3.1

  • حسنی‌صالح س، اعتصام ا، زبیحی ح. زیبایی رسانه‌ای فناوری معماری در بناهای شاخص معماری معاصر ایران. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1400;11(1):37–52. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1400.11.1.5.8

  • معارفی ع، تقی‌زاده ک، بایزیدی ق، حسین‌پور س. ارتقای عملکرد و خلاقیت دانشجویان با تمرکز بر BIM؛ مطالعه موردی درس طراحی فنی ساختمان. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1400;11(3):93–108. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1400.11.3.3.0

  • محمودی م، نیوی س. بهبود فناوری‌های اقلیمی در راستای توسعه پایدار. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1390;1(1):35–52. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1390.1.1.7.0

  • مدی ح، ایمانی م. فناوری زیست‌الهامی و یادگیری از طبیعت. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1397;8(1):47–55. https://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-26887-en.html

  • میکائیلی ر، کرمی ا، یوسفی م. بررسی و تحلیل شاخص‌های ارزیابی کیفیت مسکن معاصر ایرانی–اسلامی با استفاده از فرایند تحلیل سلسله‌مراتبی. معماری و فرهنگ شهری اسلامی. 1400;6(1):18–38. https://doi.org/10.52547/ciauj.6.1.19

  • پهلوان ا، حبیب ف، زارع ل. بررسی فناوری‌های نوین نمای ساختمان‌های بلندمرتبه مسکونی تهران از منظر الگوهای زیبایی‌شناسی. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1398;9(2):91–103. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1398.9.2.2.3

  • رسول‌زاده م، مشعری م. رویکرد طراحانه به سلامت ساکنان با تعامل انتخاب مصالح ساختمانی و محیط سالم. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1402;13(3):129–148. http://bsnt.modares.ac.ir/article-2-73856-en.html

  • رسول‌زاده م، مشعری م. اولویت‌بندی برای برنامه‌ریزی شهری سالم با تعامل شیمی نوین و مصالح سبز. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1400;11(1):94–105. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1400.11.1.7.0

  • تقوایی ع، زابتیان طرقی ا، عسگری‌زاده ز. کاربرد فناوری‌های نوین در بازتوسعه اراضی قهوه‌ای. نقش‌جهان: مبانی و فناوری‌های نوین معماری و شهرسازی. 1395;6(3):15–25. https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.23224991.1395.6.3.1.3

  • Receive Date 03 November 2025
  • Revise Date 29 November 2025
  • Accept Date 23 December 2025